Recipe: Malt Shoppe Pie

May 18, 2020 | Recipes

This recipe comes from a friend of mine. Linda Maylone was a second grade teacher for many years at West Liberty Elementary School. I first met Linda when she was a student teacher in my second grade class. Then many years later, when I was hired to teach at West Liberty Elementary School, I was able to teach with her as a colleague. Even though we’re both retired from teaching – we still keep in touch.

Malt Shoppe Pie

Bottom Layer:
1 pint softened vanilla ice cream (2 cups)
½ c. crushed malted milk balls
1 Tblsp. milk
1 9” graham cracker crust
Stir softened ice cream, ½ c. malted milk balls and 1 T. milk together.
Spread in crust and freeze while making top layer.

Top Layer:
3 Tblsp. instant choc flavored malt powder
3 Tblsp. marshmallow ice cream topping
1 Tblps. milk
1 cup whipping cream

Blend malt powder, marshmallow topping and milk. Add whipping cream and whip until soft peaks form. Spread on first layer.

Freeze until firm – about 4 hours or overnight. Sprinkle with crushed malted milk balls before serving. Can also add a spoon of cool whip on top.

Before serving, take out of freezer for a few minutes and allow to thaw slightly. Warm knife helps with cutting.

More Posts

antique lantern in the Zuber's Wagon Wheel Room

Treasures Tell Stories! Antiques, Arts, and Quilts

Winter scene of yellow baseball bat and baseball

Winter Hours Start January 3

#13 The Old Gold Hawkeye

Let’s Go Hawks!